Two boys, one nightmare: The haunting ‘mirror’ clues between the Gus Lamont and William Tyrrell disappearances that go BEYOND COINCIDENCE.

Two boys, one nightmare: The haunting ‘mirror’ clues between the Gus Lamont and William Tyrrell disappearances that go BEYOND COINCIDENCE.

When news broke that a little boy was missing from his home in South Australia and details of his family were inexplicably withheld, it all sadly seemed far too familiar.

Child safety products
 

 

Eleven years apart, William Tyrrell and Gus Lamont vanished from their grandmothers’ houses.

Coincidence theory book
From the very outset, the striking parallels and coincidences with the Tyrrell case were obvious.

As the days rolled by with the boy still unnamed, still no photo of him, no distraught parents fronting the media, and no trace of the child, the comparisons kept coming…
Family counseling services
1. SENDING IN THE FAMILY FRIEND

Australians are no strangers to scenes of trauma: a loved one vanishes – often a child with no reason to disappear – and devastated parents front the cameras, pleading for answers.

But that’s not what happened when William Tyrrell vanished. Instead of a tearful couple, we got family friend Nicole, who released photos of him.

Nicole, who went on Nine’s Today show four days after the toddler’s disappearance, said that William’s family was ‘completely distressed’ but couldn’t say who they were.

When William Tyrrell vanished, the public was left in the dark about who he or his family actually were, which worked against the investigation

The sole photo of missing Gus Lamont was not released until days after he vanished, and his family background was suppressed

The sandpit where Gus was last spotted is next to a trommel (circled along with the sandpit), a machine used for sorting earth and gold prospecting, and a mine shaft, which has no doubt been searched

In the early days of William Tyrrell’s disappearance, police, SES and volunteers searched within a small radius of his grandmother’s house where he was last seen

SES and army personnel on the ground south of Yunta, SA, where Gus Lamont was last seen just before nightfall and where the search was called off after a week and later resumed

She said William ‘did not have a tendency to wander off’ but added cryptically that the boy ‘didn’t live here [in Kendall] so he wasn’t in the bush but he was definitely outdoorsy’.
Child safety products
‘He loved being outside but he knew the limits, he knew the perimeters, he knew where to go and where not to go. He was taught really well about the places that he could play,’ Nicole said.

In the case of Gus Lamont, it was again four days afterwards that a family friend appeared before the media.

Bill Harbison said the boy’s family was ‘devastated’, adding that they were still coming to terms with what had happened.
Family counseling services
‘It has come as a shock to our family and friends and we’re struggling to comprehend what has happened,’ he said.

‘Gus’s absence is felt by all of us and we miss him more than words can express.

‘Our hearts are aching and we are holding on to hope that he will be found safe and well,’ Mr Harbison, an equine veterinarian, said.

A photo of the missing boy was, however, yet to be released by his family.

No parents to be seen, family friend Nicole instead fronted the media alongside police days after William Tyrrell – whose background was kept secret at the time – vanished
Child safety products

It wasn’t until four days after the initially unnamed missing boy vanished that a family friend, Bill Harbison, publicly appealed for information about a boy called Gus
Family counseling services
2. GRANDMA’S HOUSE AND WEALTHY FOLK

WILLIAM TYRRELL

William vanished from his foster grandmother’s house on Benaroon Drive, Kendall, on the NSW Mid North Coast, on the morning of September 12, 2014.

According to information released via Nicole by William’s foster parents and police after he vanished, his grandmother was ‘an active and well-liked member of the tight-knit Kendall community and had recently been in hospital.

‘His grandfather died earlier this year and his grandmother needed someone to care for her in the house, so William’s family had travelled from their home in Sydney to stay with her.’

This sparked a tsunami of conspiracy theories that were only partly extinguished when some facts were finally revealed: his foster parents were rich Sydney North Shore professionals, unlike his formerly 𝒹𝓇𝓊𝑔-affected birth parents.

William Tyrrell’s foster grandmother (above with a police officer) at the house where the toddler mysteriously vanished on the morning of September 12, 2014

The wealthy North Shore couple who fostered William Tyrrell, who was taken from his dysfunctional birth parents at eight months old

Family tree of Gus Lamont, starting with his great-grandparents Vincent and Clair Pfeiffer, who inherited the Oak Park property from her family
Family counseling services

Gus’s grandmother, Shannon Murray, with her daughter Jess as an infant. Jess is the mother of missing Gus Lamont, who disappeared on the evening of September 27

GUS LAMONT

Gus vanished from his grandmothers’ 60-square-kilometre rural property in Far North South Australia on the evening of September 27, 2025.

Gus was staying with Shannon and Josie Murray – his grandmother and trans grandmother, respectively – at Oak Park, a remote sheep station inherited from Shannon’s parents.

Josie used to be Robert Murray, but began identifying as a woman later in life. Robert and Shannon had married and welcomed a daughter, Jess, Gus’ mother. It’s unclear if their marriage is still intact after Josie’s transition, but they do still live together.

Citizens of Yunta speak highly of the Murrays. Shannon’s late father, Vincent Pfeiffer, who ran the farm until his death in the 2010s, was a famously tough man who survived three years in a Japanese prisoner-of-war camp during World War II.

Gus Lamont’s other grandmother, trans woman Josie Murray, is seen at the Oak Park property where Gus was last sighted playing on a sand heap next to a gold prospecting machine

After returning to Australia, he married Shannon’s mother, Clair Jones, and began working on the farm. A pillar of the community, he was an active member of the town’s rifle shooting club.

In more recent times, the family has been involved in the Yunta Race Club, which stages amateur ‘gymkhanas’ at which competitors race everything from horses to motorbikes.
Family counseling services
3. A BLACK EYE?

The last time William Tyrrell’s birth mother saw her son alive was on an access visit – and she had been warned beforehand that the three-year-old had a black eye, which he had sustained ‘from an accidental fall’ at his foster parents’ home.

It was not the first time William had fallen over, and detectives would later theorise the little boy had died after accidentally falling from his grandmother’s verandah.
Child safety products

William Tyrrell had a black left eye – as confirmed by carers – just before he vanished in September 2014, with child welfare workers saying it had been sustained during an accidental fall at his foster parents’ home

The area below Gus’s right eye looks to be swollen and slightly darker than the corresponding area under his left eye, leading to online speculation that it is a black eye

In the case of Gus Lamont, there have been no statements from his family about the young boy’s life on the station, or about any incidents that might have caused the black eye seemingly visible in the only publicly available photograph of him.
Family counseling services
That image, released by his family six days after he vanished, is of publicly unknown vintage, but would seem to depict a boy of about four.

The area below Gus’s right eye looks to be swollen and slightly darker than the corresponding area under his left eye. Daily Mail makes no suggestion the black eye – if indeed it is one – is the result of anything besides an innocent accident.

4. ICONIC PHOTO

The iconic photo of William Tyrrell roaring in his Spider-Man suit is said to be one of the last images of him ever taken before he mysteriously vanished from his foster grandmother’s verandah.
Child safety products
The last photos – taken on a camera the foster mother had bought in Bali just weeks before William went missing – were considered the final ‘proof of life’ for William.

They hold time stamps that themselves have become the subject of dispute over when the boy vanished.

The picture of Gus Lamont with his long, wavy blond hair is the sole photo of the missing four-year-old released since he disappeared, and has become a similarly defining image of the case.

The iconic photo of William Tyrrell roaring for the camera on the morning he went missing in 2014. No trace of the three-year-old has ever been found
Family counseling services

The only photo of Gus Lamont, four, released to the public days after the boy vanished from his grandmother’s homestead on the Oak Park property in northern South Australia 
Child safety products
5. THE MISSING HOURS

The iconic photo of William emitting a playful roar was used as crucial ‘proof of life’ evidence by investigators to establish a time frame for his disappearance.

The ‘proof of life’ timeframe was based on when the image was taken (9.37am) and when his foster mother called the police (10.57am).

However, that timeline was thrown into doubt by the photo’s digital metadata that suggested the picture may have been taken earlier.

The image has a ‘created time’ of 7.39am and a ‘corrected time’ of 9.37am, a document from the 2000-page evidence brief showed in 2021.

Time stamp on the final photos of William Tyrrell on his grandmother’s verandah show ‘created’ and ‘corrected’ times with a two hour discrepancy

With the sun starting to sink, concern quickly turned to panic as darkness engulfed the property. The family did not call police for a further three hours 
Family counseling services
Gus was last seen outside by his grandmother at 5pm, then was absent when she went to call him in for dinner around 5:30pm.

With the sun starting to sink, concern quickly turned to panic.

Sunset on September 27 was officially 6.11pm and for the next three hours, family members told police, they frantically explored the rambling homestead, shouting Gus’s name into the twilight.

An hour after twilight gave way to darkness – at 8.30pm – they called the police.

It is not suggested that any members of Gus’ family had any involvement in his disappearance.

6. FAMILY TIES

William, born on his mother’s 23rd birthday, was removed from his biological parents, who both have 𝒹𝓇𝓊𝑔 convictions, aged just seven months, in early 2012.

The birth mother was preparing to fight a move by William’s foster parents to adopt him when he disappeared.

When William vanished, police and welfare authorities turned up immediately at the birth parents’ Sydney home and found nothing.

William Tyrrell’s foster parents and grandmother gather on the verandah of the home from where he went missing in the wake of the foster mother calling police about William. The boy’s foster father (right) at the scene
Child safety products

Jess and Josh Lamont, the parents of missing Gus, have had their identities kept private by SA Police, even though it is policing 101 in missing child cases to have the families face the press
Family counseling services
Gus’ parents, Jess and Josh Lamont, have remained largely a mystery in the wake of their son’s disappearance.

The couple also have a second son, one-year-old Ronnie, but have lived apart recently after a family dispute, with Josh keeping a home two hours’ drive away.

Josh was the frontman of country rock ‘n’ roll band The Cut Snakes, which performed in rural South Australian bars and pubs in 2019, winning a local music award.

Late on September 27 – the night Gus disappeared – police found Josh asleep at his home. It’s believed he’s since been ruled out as having any involvement in the case.

William’s birth father (left) told his missing son’s inquest that the NSW child welfare bureaucrats ‘f**ked up’, and his birth mother (right) rolls her eyes at suppression orders over names, saying ‘they know who we are anyway’

7. TRAMPLING THE CRIME SCENE & NEW SEARCHES

It’s the classic dilemma which later can be considered a bungle.

When there’s a lost boy in the bush, get the boots on the ground to find him before sunset on the same day – or, in the case of Gus Lamont, on the second day after a shivering night in the open.
Child safety products
When police fail to find any trace of the child, they will mount a wider search and, when that fails, doubt will set in – but by that time, the scene of the disappearance is a trampled mess.

The initial search for Gus was similar to that for William 11 years previously – in a relatively small radius of 2km and involving helicopters, drones, infrared cameras, trail bikes, and teams of divers who explored the farm’s water tanks, ponds and reservoirs.

SES and police do a line search on the vast property where the four-year-old vanished on September 27

The search for William in the days after he disappeared near Kendall, on the NSW Mid North Coast, in 2014 soon turned from a missing child probe to possible abduction

With William, police dogs were deployed on the properties up and down Benaroon Drive, the street where he disappeared which had been overrun by authorities and volunteers scouring it for the boy.
Child safety products
When sniffer and cadaver dogs failed to pick up the three-year-old’s scent, Superintendent Paul Fehon admitted: ‘We do have grave concerns. To disappear that quickly absolutely bewilders us.’

Police contacted known local 𝒔𝒆𝒙 offenders and widened the already massive search.

Within six days, it shifted from bushland around his grandmother’s street to the Middle Brother State Forest 5km away.

Police search the foster grandmother’s house at Kendall in 2021 – one of several searches that failed to find any trace of little William

Forever young: William Tyrrell in what was the last year of his life after a NSW Supreme Court judge found the boy was most likely dead since someone disposed of him in 2014
Child safety products

Gary Jubelin, the since-removed strike force commander, in his trademark black suit and tie, leads a bushland search in 2018, which found nothing

In the years since, second, third and further searches – the last major one was in 2021 – have failed to find any trace of little William.

With hindsight, failing to secure Benaroon Drive has been described as a police failure. It is not suggested that any members of William Tyrrell’s family had any involvement in his disappearance.
Family counseling services
Following Gus’s disappearance, for a week, investigators scoured the enormous Oak Park Station, which covers an astonishing 6,000 hectares of scrubland and desert.

Every morning, convoys of trucks negotiated the 29km dirt drive, bringing teams from the outskirts of the local town, Yunta, which has a population of 60.

They scoured rocky landscape covered with salt bushes and other shrubs, making it all too easy for a child to disappear; however, after a week it was scaled back and then halted.

Then on Tuesday, October 14, the search resumed.

The search resumed for missing Gus Lamont October 14, with police saying they were now looking outside of the original location

South Australian Police Commissioner Grant Stevens said: ‘The search area that was originally canvassed was established on the basis of expert advice regarding just how far a four-year-old child was likely to travel, the implications of being alone and unprotected in the environment, survivability factors and medical advice as well.

‘The location we’re now searching is outside of the original… location.’

By Wednesday, police said the renewed search had so far yielded ‘no new evidence’ but continued in hot windy conditions as temperatures were tipped to soar to 36°C.

‘More than 100 search team members, including SA Police, ADF members and SES volunteers, have each been walking between 20 and 25km each day in hot, harsh conditions,’ SA Police said in a statement on Wednesday.

8. ABDUCTION?

When William Tyrrell disappeared, many people’s minds turned to a possible abduction.

This was fuelled early on by his foster mother saying she believed he had been ‘taken’, followed by her later descriptions of two ‘dirty old’ cars – an element that police could not corroborate and residents of the quiet street disputed.

Detectives interviewed several known child 𝒔𝒆𝒙 offenders in the region, but eventually discounted them and pursued alleged sightings of William in a fleeing car.

None of the clues came to anything, and no one has been charged with William’s disappearance.

William was a lively boy but did not venture far on his own, casting doubts on the suggestion he would have wandered or gone quietly with any potential abductor
Child safety products
The situation for Gus Lamont was different in that he vanished from a remote station onto which no known strangers had driven that afternoon.

Rescue workers are said to have discounted several theories that might explain the four-year-old’s disappearance.

While dingoes have been known to abduct small children, there are precious few in the land around Yunta as the local sheep farmers tend to shoot them on sight.

The region is also protected by a 2000km dog fence designed to safeguard livestock. Crocodiles, which inhabit more tropical northern regions of Australia, are not found in the south.

Gus is too big to be taken by an eagle, and if he had been attacked by a wild pig, searchers would almost certainly have discovered evidence of a struggle.

9. SEARCH ERRORS & AN ENDURING MYSTERY

The William Tyrrell investigation was flawed by police mistakes, meaning the mystery of what happened to him may never be solved.

Key Tyrrell figure Allanna Smith claimed that defensive police, operational errors and keeping family details from the public may have obstructed the hunt for the child.
Family counseling services
She described the Gus Lamont case as ‘in some ways a carbon copy of William’.

Key Tyrrell figure Allanna Smith claimed that defensive police, operational errors and keeping family details from the public may have obstructed the hunt for the child

She said that in contrast to Tyrrell, for whom there has never been any trace, a child-sized footprint had been found in the search for Gus – although it has since been dismissed by police – but as far as she is concerned: ‘I’m not buying it.’

‘That property is covered with fine dust – you can see it blowing around in footage of the search,’ she said.

‘I don’t care if you are four, or a mouse or a rat, you leave some impression in that powdery red dust.

‘So the cops went on the property and basically destroyed the scene.’

The Daily Mail is not suggesting that any member of Gus or William’s family or their spokespeople obstructed the search for the missing boys.