The recent double homicide of Spencer Tepe, a beloved Ohio dentist, and his wife Monique Tepe has left their community in mourning, with tributes highlighting Spencer’s exceptional kindness and the profound positive impact he had on Monique’s life after her difficult previous marriage.
A colleague of Spencer Tepe shared heartfelt words in remembrance: “He was the kindest man I knew; he truly saved Monique Tepe’s soul when they came together.” This sentiment captures the essence of how friends and coworkers viewed the couple’s relationship—a beacon of healing, love, and stability amid tragedy.
Spencer L. Tepe, 37, and Monique F. Tepe, 39, were found fatally shot in their Weinland Park home in Columbus, Ohio, on December 30, 2025. The discovery followed a welfare check initiated by Spencer’s colleagues at Athens Dental Depot after he failed to appear for work and Monique did not respond to calls. Police arrived to a heartbreaking scene: the couple had been shot—Spencer suffering multiple gunshot wounds and Monique at least one to the chest—while their two young children, Emilia and Beckham (ages approximately 4 and 1), and family dog remained unharmed inside the residence. There were no signs of forced entry, theft, or a broader struggle, pointing away from a random burglary or home invasion.
The couple, who would have celebrated their fifth wedding anniversary soon after, were described in their joint obituary and family statements as “the life of the party,” generous hosts who filled their home with family and friends. Spencer, a graduate of Ohio State University and member of the American Dental Association, was remembered as deeply committed to serving others. Colleagues from his previous practice in Ashland, Ohio, echoed this, noting his “happy presence” and role as a devoted mentor. One former coworker recalled, “We’re going to miss him… But his memory is going to be in our hearts forever.” Monique was portrayed as a “loving, patient, and joyful mother” whose warmth defined her—an excellent baker, thoughtful planner, and someone who brought people together.
Family members, including Monique’s brother-in-law Rob Misleh, emphasized the couple’s warmth: “You never saw them without a smile on their face… They were so warm. Their place in Columbus was just where everybody gathered.” Misleh highlighted their devotion to their children, Spencer’s love of golf, and Monique’s passion for running. The family statement described them as “extraordinary people whose lives were filled with love, joy, and a deep connection to others.”
The investigation quickly centered on domestic violence-related motives. Monique’s ex-husband, Michael David McKee, a 39-year-old vascular surgeon living and working in Illinois (associated with OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center in Rockford), emerged as the primary suspect. The pair had married in 2015 but divorced in 2017 after a short, reportedly tumultuous relationship marked by emotional abuse. Family accounts, including from Misleh, revealed Monique had confided that McKee threatened her life “many times” during their marriage. She was said to have been “willing to do anything” to escape the relationship, describing patterns of control and fear that contrasted sharply with the happiness she found with Spencer.
McKee was arrested on January 10, 2026, in Rockford, Illinois, at a Chick-fil-A, shortly after charges were filed in Ohio: two counts of aggravated murder with premeditation. He waived extradition and was held pending transfer, though delays occurred. In court, a public defender indicated a not-guilty plea was planned.
On January 14, 2026, Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant held a press conference announcing a major breakthrough. Authorities described the killings as a “targeted domestic violence-related” attack with McKee as the sole perpetrator. Key evidence included:
Surveillance footage showing a person of interest in a dark alley near the Tepe home on the night of the murders, now believed to be McKee.
Vehicle tracking data placing a car registered to McKee in the area before and after the homicides, after a long drive from Illinois (over 400 miles).
No weapon at the initial crime scene, but ballistic evidence (including 9mm casings) provided leads.
A search of McKee’s Lincoln Park condo in Chicago recovered multiple firearms. One underwent preliminary testing via the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN) and matched casings and wounds from the scene. Chief Bryant stated: “We believe at this point we have the person responsible for the murders of Monique and Spencer Tepe, and that person is Michael McKee.” The gun is considered the murder weapon, fully consistent with the evidence.
Family reactions were unsurprised by the arrest. Relatives and friends had long worried about McKee, citing Monique’s past fears. In contrast, her life with Spencer was stable and loving, built in Columbus post-divorce. McKee’s professional life as a surgeon added irony to the case, though no prior criminal record was noted publicly (separate malpractice issues surfaced in reports).
As of January 15, 2026, McKee awaits extradition and arraignment in Franklin County, Ohio. Prosecutors have not fully disclosed motive, but the domestic violence context suggests unresolved jealousy or control issues from the divorce. Experts note such cases often involve lingering resentment when an ex-partner finds new happiness.
The tragedy highlights domestic violence’s long-term dangers, even years after separation. The Tepe children’s survival amid horror has sparked widespread sympathy and community support in Columbus, including private vigils. Amid grief, tributes focus on legacy: Spencer’s kindness, Monique’s joy, and the healing their union represented. As one colleague poignantly said, Spencer “saved Monique’s soul”—a testament to love triumphing over past pain, now forever remembered.
