Case Against California Man Accused of Raping Daughter Who Died by Suicide May Be Dismissed
GoFundMe
The relatives of an 18-year-old woman who died by suicide after she was allegedly raped by her biological father are concerned the case against him will be dismissed, because she can no longer testify against him.
“The DA was essentially saying, ‘We don’t know if we have a case because she’s no longer here,’ and when she told me that, I immediately said, ‘No, we’re not going to let that slide,’” Crystal Sandoval said of her late cousin, Makayla Rene Settles, while speaking to FOX LA.
Makayla was living in Raleigh, North Carolina, when she turned 18 and decided to move to Moorpark, California, to live with her biological father, Stephen Vincent Chavez.
Sandoval said she had plans to attend college and plant roots out west.
But on July 21, 2025, Makayla called home to North Carolina two days after moving, and “it was just the fear in her voice, her crying … I didn’t need details. I knew something was wrong, and I said, ‘I’m on the way,’” said her mom, Carolina Sandoval, to FOX LA.
Father Pleads Guilty to Murder After Starving 50-Pound Daughter, 12, During ‘Years’ of Abuse
Carolina said when she saw her daughter later, she couldn’t believe it. “She’s barely walking,” Carolina said. “My brother picks her up and hugs her.”
A rape kit was completed on Makayla at a nearby hospital, which allegedly determined seminal fluid recovered during the sexual assault forensic exam tested positive for Stephen’s DNA. The father was arrested that same night for incest, taking advantage of a position of trust, and providing alcohol to a minor.
“I was screaming, I was crying. I just kept thinking, why would he do that to her?” Sandoval said. “This is something she could not come back from.”
On December 28, 2025, Makayla died by suicide. “If I’m being honest, it feels like I handed my daughter to the devil,” Carolina confided to the station.
She said Stephen texted Makayla while she was in the hospital, saying, “I’m never drinking liquor again. I don’t want that blackout to happen again.”
Sandoval said they are devastated to learn from the Ventura County District Attorney’s Office the case may not go to trial because of Makayla’s death.
Sandoval said she went on social media to demand justice and has managed to get hundreds of people to commit to showing up to Chavez’s next court hearing, which is set for April 21 at the Ventura County Courthouse.
“It was like he took her sunshine away and just kind of broke her soul,” Sandoval said.
The Ventura County District Attorney’s Office, in a statement, said it was aware of Sandoval’s social media campaign.
Stepfather of 19-Year-Old Who Vanished 10 Years Ago Arrested, Charged With Sex Offenses
“Our Sexual Assault Unit continues to prosecute the defendant for this extremely serious crime,” the statement explained. “This case has been filed since July 2025, when the evidence supported the filing of felony charges. As with any case, prosecutors filed charges based on the evidence. The court sets bail. Our office successfully moved to increase bail to $250K in July 2025 when the case was filed.”
It added: “The defendant requested that bail be reduced, but we successfully argued against that. The defendant has since posted $250K bail and is out of custody. With respect to the upcoming hearing, the April 21 date is an early disposition conference. This is a standard pretrial proceeding where the court and parties address the status of the case and set future dates as appropriate.”
Still, Makayla’s loved ones insist they’ve been told not to expect a trial.
Us Weekly was unable to connect with anyone in the prosecutor’s office.
If you or someone you know has been a victim of sexual violence, text “STRENGTH” to the Crisis Text Line at 741-741 to be connected to a certified crisis counselor.
News
“FINISH HER…” — the two words now at the center of the Scarlett Faulkner case. According to investigators, this wasn’t just a fight that spiraled out of control — it may have been something far more calculated. 😨🚗 Prosecutors allege that while the violence was happening, someone wasn’t just present… they were directing it. Sitting nearby. Watching. And, according to testimony, giving instructions that would change everything. 💀 One moment in particular is now drawing intense attention — a line that’s being described as chilling, and possibly key to understanding what really happened that night. Was this a situation that escalated… or something more controlled from the start? As more details come out, the case is raising deeper questions about influence, intent, and who is truly responsible. 👇 👉 Read more in the comments below…
“Finish Her”: The Chilling Tactical Confession of Scarlett Faulkner’s Mastermind — How a Leaked Testimony Exposed the Heartless Coach Behind the 16-Year-Old’s Final Moments A Masterclass in Cruelty The investigation into the tragic death of 16-year-old Scarlett Faulkner has shifted from a teenage brawl to a calculated execution. Leaked testimonies reveal that the accused mastermind was […]
A TODDLER. A PARKED SUV. AND A TRAGEDY NO ONE SAW COMING. 2-year-old Lucia Ayala lost her life in what investigators are calling a devastating accident — inside her parents’ brand new Hyundai SUV in Akron, Ohio. 😢 According to officials, Lucia became trapped when a power-folding rear seat suddenly moved forward, compressing her. The medical examiner later ruled her death as accidental, caused by mechanical asphyxia. ⚰️ But what’s leaving people shaken is how quickly everything unfolded… and how something so routine turned into something unthinkable. Bodycam footage shows the frantic moments that followed — officers rushing in, bystanders trying to help, CPR being performed as her father stood nearby, trying to understand how it could have happened. 💔 He reportedly told police the seat “wasn’t working,” desperately attempting to move it back up. Investigators say a button may have been pressed, triggering the seat to fold — but exactly how it happened is still under review. Meanwhile, Hyundai has issued a recall for the model involved as questions continue to grow. 🚨 Those who knew Lucia remember her as a bright, joyful little girl — her name meaning “light,” something her family says she truly was in their lives. 🕊️ Now, as the investigation continues, one heartbreaking question remains: how could something like this happen… and could it have been prevented? 📌 👉 Read more in the comments below…
Lucia Natalia Ayala It is with heavy hearts and unimaginable grief that the family of Lucia Natalia announces her passing on March 7, 2026. Our Lucia was born on February 8, 2024 as a cherished gift from God. She was named with intention, as Lucia means “light,” and never has a name been more perfectly […]
TAKEN INTO CUSTODY AT HER OWN GRAVESIDE… the moment no one expected, but many say raises even more questions. Niomi Rose’s aunt is now facing a second-degree murder charge, and the case is taking a turn that has people across the community shaken. 💔⚰️ But beyond the arrest, there’s a deeper frustration that’s been building. Niomi had once been in a loving, stable home — a place where she was reportedly safe and cared for. Then she was moved. And now, people are asking why that decision was ever made in the first place. Because what followed has led to one of the most heartbreaking outcomes imaginable. And for many, this isn’t just about one person being charged — it’s about the chain of decisions that may have put her at risk. 🚨 Questions about the system, about placement choices, about whether more could have been done… they’re all coming to the surface now. And as this case unfolds, one thing is clear: people don’t just want answers — they want change. 🕊️ 📌 👉 Read more in the comments below…
Beaten, Then Lost Forever: The Death of 4-Year-Old Niomi Rose and the Standoff That Followed Beaten, Then Lost Forever: The Death of 4-Year-Old Niomi Rose Ends in a SWAT Standoff and a Community Searching for Answers The death of a child is always devastating, but when that death comes from violence inside a place meant […]
A FINAL PHONE CALL… AND NOW A FAMILY DEMANDING ANSWERS. Ashlee Jenae, known online as Ashly Robinson, was found dead in Zanzibar — but her parents say the official explanation doesn’t match what they know. 😨⚰️ Just before everything happened, she called them, saying she was in a heated argument with her fiancé. According to her mom, it got so serious that hotel staff had to step in and separate them into different rooms. 🚩🚩 And that detail is now raising major concerns. Because not long after that call… she was gone. Authorities have labeled it a su!c!de, but her family isn’t convinced. They say too many things don’t line up — the argument, the timing, the sudden conclusion. And now, they’re refusing to stay silent. They want real answers. And they’re even planning to travel to Zanzibar themselves to find out what really happened in those final hours. 📌 👉 Read more in the comments below…
Ashlee Jenae’s Parents Reveal Fiancé Joe McCann Waited 11 Hours to Call After She Was Found Unconscious, Then Went Silent. The family of 31-year-old influencer Ashly Robinson, known online as Ashlee Jenae, is speaking out with growing concern over the circumstances surrounding her sudden death in Zanzibar. What was intended as a joyful birthday and […]
HE POSTED ABOUT HIS STRUGGLES… THEN HOURS LATER, EVERYTHING CHANGED. Shamar Elkins is now at the center of a devastating case involving the deaths of eight children — including seven of his own. 💔😱 Before it happened, he shared photos with them, moments that looked completely normal. But buried in an earlier post was something far more troubling: a message about fighting inner demons, asking God to protect his mind. Now, that message is being re-examined by thousands online. Was it a sign of something breaking beneath the surface? Or an attempt to shape the narrative before the truth came out? 🚨 Either way, the gap between what was shown publicly and what allegedly happened next is deeply disturbing.
8 kids massacred by deranged Army vet dad Shamar Elkins in Louisiana shooting ID’d The eight young children gunned down by their deranged Army veteran father and uncle during a harrowing domestic violence massacre in Louisiana early Sunday have been identified. The children were formally identified by their mothers, according to a news release from the Caddo […]
A FATHER’S GRIEF… AND ONE REQUEST THE WORLD CAN’T IGNORE. After losing his 12-year-old daughter, he’s speaking out with a message that’s spreading fast: stop focusing on the one responsible, and start remembering the children. 💔🕊️ He says his daughter was full of dreams, creativity, and a joy that filled their home every single day. But now, all he has left is a memory — watching her leave for school, a moment that now feels impossible to move past. 🚪 And as more details come out, what he shared about her final moments is something people say will stay with them…
HEARTBROKEN FATHER BEGS WORLD TO REMEMBER HIS DAUGHTER—NOT THE SHOOTER AFTER SCHOOL MASSACRE. In the aftermath of a devastating school tragedy, a grieving father has emerged with a message that cuts through the noise of headlines and speculation, urging the world to shift its focus away from violence and toward the innocent lives that […]
End of content
No more pages to load
