A Former FBI Agent Reveals the Shocking Reason No Vehicle Was Ever Found in the Mysterious Kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie — Investigators Missed It for Days, and the Truth Is Almost Impossible to Believe

The maze of unlit streets and lack of traffic cameras in Nancy Guthrie’s remote Arizona neighborhood would have made it easier for her abductor to take her away in a car and avoid surveillance, a former FBI agent has claimed.

Authorities on Tuesday released footage showing a suspect approaching the door of the 84-year-old’s Tucson, Arizona, home, but no vehicle has yet been identified as belonging to the alleged kidnapper.

Nancy’s remote, pitch-black Catalina Foothills neighborhood is not doing investigators any favors, according to retired FBI agent James Gagliano, who said that it would have been easy for the suspect to navigate backstreets and avoid cameras.

Savannah Guthrie and Nancy Guthrie sitting side-by-side, smiling.
The search for “Today” show co-host Savannah Guthrie’s mother, Nancy, has entered its 11th day.savannahguthrie/Instagram
 

“I want you to think about Manhattan. This is exactly the opposite to that. This is almost like a Jackson Pollock painting,” Gagliano told Fox & Friends on Wednesday. “The way that the routes go in and out, the ingress could have been one way, and the egress could have been a different way.”

“There are multiple exits here. Some of them are covered by those dome traffic lights that keep an eye on traffic, determine whether or not the signals are working on time, and keep in line the traffic patterns. Some of them aren’t,” he continued.

“So is it possible if the suspect left via vehicle, he would not have been picked up by a license plate reader or one of these cameras? The answer is yes.”

Gagliano said it is unlikely that Nancy’s kidnapper came and left on foot.

A newly released black and white photo shows a masked suspect outside the Arizona home of Nancy Guthrie.
Guthrie’s abductor could have more easily avoided being seen by surveillance due to the maze of unlit streets and lack of traffic dome cameras in the 84-year-old’s neighborhood, a former FBI agent has claimed.FBI via Getty Images

Aerial view of Nancy Guthrie’s house, identified as a crime scene in Tucson, Arizona.
Nancy Guthrie’s house as of Feb. 2 in Tucson, Arizona.Rebecca Noble for NY Post
While the abductor making off with an elderly woman without a vehicle seems far-fetched, Gagliano pointed out that there are few fences between properties, which would make an escape via the secluded backyards possible.

“They don’t have fences out here; the properties butt up against each other, there’s no cyclone fencing or anything restricting access between the properties,” he said.

Gagliano was speaking after authorities detained an individual for questioning on Tuesday evening following a traffic stop in Rio Rico, Arizona, just south of Tucson.

The man, a FedEx delivery driver named Carlos Palazuelos, added that his house in Rio Rico was also searched as part of the investigation before he was released without charge.

Aerial view of Nancy Guthrie's house in Tucson, Arizona, surrounded by desert landscaping and other homes.
“This is almost like a Jackson Pollock painting … The way that the routes go in and out, the ingress could have been one way, and the egress could have been a different way,” retired FBI agent James Gagliano said.Rebecca Noble for the NY Post
As of Wednesday, no other individuals have been detained in connection with the disappearance of Nancy, who was last seen after being dropped off at her Catalina Foothills home on the evening of Jan. 31.

Savannah put out another message on social media Tuesday, saying she and her family still believe her mother is alive.

“We believe she is still out there. Bring her home,” she said.

At the same time, renewed search activity has intensified near her daughter and son-in-law’s home, fueling speculation that investigators may be working off a new lead they haven’t publicly acknowledged. Authorities are refusing to confirm what the footage means — or whether it changes the direction of the investigation.  Online, viewers are dissecting every second of the video — analyzing posture, movement, even the way the figure turns their head — convinced a critical clue is hiding in plain sight.  If this wasn’t about money… then what was it about?  Officials remain tight-lipped. The tension is rising. And the questions are multiplying faster than answers.
Malehya now alleges that during a heated confrontation, Martell physically restrained her, pushed her, and ripped her phone from her hands as she tried to call her mother — leaving her in pain and cut off from help.  But that’s only part of what has investigators quietly zeroing in.  Sources say authorities are examining a chilling possibility: that amid the chaos inside the home, her children may have slipped out through a back door — unnoticed, unaccounted for, and potentially exposed to something far worse.  As statements shift and key moments remain unanswered, one question is growing louder: what really happened behind those closed doors… and who managed to escape before the situation spiraled beyond control?
cameras captured heartbreak — trembling voices, candlelight vigils, promises that no stone would be left unturned. But officials now claim those emotional appeals were part of something far darker: a calculated performance designed to hide a devastating truth.  Sources say critical timeline inconsistencies, forensic findings, and behind-the-scenes evidence unraveled the official narrative piece by piece — until it collapsed entirely.  If this is true, it means the public wasn’t witnessing a tragedy unfold… but a script being carried out.
Doctors say the procedure was successful. Recovery has begun. But insiders admit the road back won’t just be physical — it could redefine the future of her career entirely. At this stage, nothing is guaranteed.  For an athlete who has already battled injuries that would have ended most careers, this latest setback feels different. More fragile. More final.  Is this just another comeback story in the making… or the moment the snow finally lets her go?