Crime
Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping: New Theory Suggests Personal Grievance, Not Robbery Could be Main Motive
Family and authorities continue the search for the missing 84-year-old amid new theories and challenges
By
Share on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on RedditShare on FlipboardShare on Pocket
Savannah Guthrie has revisited the end of her first marriage to BBC journalist Mark Orchard, describing a divorce that ‘broke my heart’ and took ‘years to recover’ from. Suresh Prajapat @SURESHK27439361 / X
Nancy Guthrie has been missing for almost a month, but her family has not given up hope of finding the 84-year-old, who was taken from her home in Tucson, Arizona, by an unidentified man. Her daughter, Savannah Guthrie, has been publicly pleading for help, while detectives and FBI agents continue working through forensic evidence gathered at the scene.
A former FBI agent has now put forward a new theory suggesting the kidnapper may have acted out of a personal grievance rather than financial motivation — a claim that shifts the focus away from ransom and towards the possibility that Nancy may have known her abductor.
Does Nancy Guthrie Know Her Kidnapper?
$6 Million Bitcoin Ransom Deadline for Savannah Guthrie’s Missing Mom Passes: ‘Probably Hoax’
Read more
$6 Million Bitcoin Ransom Deadline for Savannah Guthrie’s Missing Mom Passes: ‘Probably Hoax’
Following the kidnapping, members of Nancy’s family came under scrutiny as possible suspects but were cleared last week. A spokesperson for the sheriff’s office said the family had been fully cooperative and that suspecting them of involvement was unfounded. Investigators have released an image of the kidnapper’s face to the public, though his identity has not been confirmed.
Jonny Grusing, a former agent with the FBI’s Denver Division, shared his analysis with Fox News, arguing that the kidnapper likely had a personal score to settle. Grusing noted that the suspect appeared to be wearing thick gloves, which would have made it difficult to fire a real weapon, leading him to conclude the gun may have been a prop.
‘So, if the gun’s a prop, if he’s shielding himself from being seen, if he’s actually ringing the doorbell or knocking on the door, getting her to come, he wants to confront her about something in my opinion,’ he told Fox News.
He also raised the possibility that Nancy recognised the suspect during the encounter, which may have caused both parties to panic. Grusing said ransom was unlikely to have been the primary motive because the kidnapper made no immediate contact with the family to demand money.
Pima County Sheriff’s Department spokesperson Angelica Carrillo said forensic teams face challenges separating DNA collected from the property, but that laboratory experts continue working through the analysis.
Savannah Guthrie Pleads for Help
Nancy’s three children have been urging the public to assist in locating their mother. Last week, Savannah uploaded a video on Instagram urging whoever is involved in the kidnapping to bring her mother home, writing in her caption that it is never too late to do the right thing.
She also shared a tribute video professing her love for Nancy and pledging that she and her siblings would never give up. In a separate clip, the siblings addressed a ransom demand from the kidnapper directly, confirming they had been unable to produce the money requested.
Where is Nancy Guthrie Now?
Investigators have not ruled out the possibility that Nancy was transported across the Mexican border, though reports suggest this did not happen immediately after the kidnapping. According to those reports, Nancy may have been moved only after her children were unable to meet the ransom demand. Her whereabouts remain unknown as the investigation continues.
News
My Mother-in-Law Tore My Clothes Apart, Thinking I Lived Off Her Son… The Next Day, She Lost Her House, Her Job, and Her Pride The sound of fabric ripping was so sharp and violent that, for a second, it felt like the entire kitchen had split in half.
**SHE RIPPED MY CLOTHES APART IN MY OWN KITCHEN—CALLING ME A GOLD DIGGER LIVING OFF HER SON… BUT WHEN I PRESSED “SEND” ON ONE EMAIL THE NEXT MORNING, SHE LOST HER HOUSE, HER JOB, AND THE ONE THING SHE THOUGHT SHE COULD NEVER LOSE—CONTROL.** — ## CHAPTER 1: THE SOUND THAT ENDED EVERYTHING The fabric […]
I THOUGHT I WAS JUST PICKING UP MY BELONGINGS… UNTIL I HEARD MY DAUGHTER SCREAMING FROM INSIDE A FREEZER—AND REALIZED SOME DOORS DON’T JUST HIDE SECRETS… THEY HIDE WHAT PEOPLE DON’T WANT FOUND.
I THOUGHT I WAS JUST PICKING UP MY BELONGINGS… UNTIL I HEARD MY DAUGHTER SCREAMING FROM INSIDE A FREEZER—AND REALIZED SOME DOORS DON’T JUST HIDE SECRETS… THEY HIDE WHAT PEOPLE DON’T WANT FOUND. CHAPTER 1: THE SOUND THAT SHOULDN’T EXIST The scream didn’t sound real. It was thin. Distorted. Like it had to claw its […]
ON MY EIGHTEENTH BIRTHDAY, MY FATHER SLID A $10,000 INVOICE ACROSS THE TABLE IN FRONT OF OUR ENTIRE FAMILY AND SAID IT WAS TIME I STARTED PAYING HIM BACK FOR THE COST OF RAISING ME
ON MY EIGHTEENTH BIRTHDAY, MY FATHER SLID A $10,000 BILL ACROSS THE TABLE AND CALLED IT “THE COST OF RAISING ME”… BUT WHEN I OPENED A BLUE FOLDER THAT PROVED HE OWED ME FIVE TIMES THAT—AND KEPT MY HAND RESTING ON THE SYSTEM THAT COULD SHUT HIS ENTIRE RESTAURANT DOWN—THE ROOM DIDN’T JUST GO SILENT… […]
At 3:47 a.m., my father called me to a “family emergency”… but when I saw the red convertible in the driveway and they asked for access to my accounts, I realized they didn’t want to help me. They wanted everything.
At exactly 3:47 a.m., my phone lit up with a message that didn’t feel like a warning… it felt like a summons. By 10:00 a.m., I was sitting in my father’s study—staring at a brand-new red convertible in the driveway—and realizing something cold, sharp, and irreversible: This wasn’t a family emergency. This was an extraction. […]
My daughter-in-law called while I was on the balcony of the beach condo I spent thirty years earning and said, “My parents need privacy, so you’ll have to stay in a hotel.”
They thought I had stepped aside. They thought silence meant surrender. They thought age meant I would choose peace over truth. They were wrong. CHAPTER 6: THE PERSON THEY DIDN’T EXPECT When the door opened fully, the house seemed to shrink. Not physically. But in the way power shifts when someone unexpected walks into a […]
They thought the storm would erase everything. The rain. The darkness. The silence of the lake swallowing a secret no one would ever question. They believed one cruel decision could disappear without consequence.
The rain poured heavily that night, turning the quiet road beside Silver Lake into a glistening ribbon of darkness. Inside a sleek black luxury car, Richard Miller drove slowly along the empty road. The windshield wipers swept back and forth in a steady rhythm, cutting through the sheets of rain that blurred the world outside. […]
End of content
No more pages to load
