We Don’t Know Why”: Police Reveal Troubling Dead End in Nancy Guthrie Case as Speculation of a Revenge Plot Sends Shockwaves Through the Community

An act of revenge has not been ruled out as a possible motive for Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, according to Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos.

In an interview with the Daily Mail published on Monday, Feb. 16, Nanos revealed that detectives are still determining the intentions of the suspects involved in Nancy’s vanishing. The 84-year-old mother of Today show co-host Savannah Guthrie was reported missing on Feb. 1, having been last seen at her Tuscon, Arizona, home the day before.

Nanos explained to the Mail why he believes Nancy was kidnapped, rather than the victim of a burglary gone wrong.

“This is somebody who’s disappeared from the face of the earth, and now we have a camera that says here’s the person who did this,” he told the outlet, referring to the masked intruder captured on a camera at her home.

Savannah and Nancy Guthrie.savannahguthrie/Instagram

Nanos continued, “And that’s what makes me say this is a kidnapping. The motivation for it is where we get stuck, right? Is it for money? I mean, we had the one demand where they asked for money. But is it really for money, or is it for revenge for something?”

The sheriff, who has 50 years of experience in law enforcement, revealed that up to 50,000 tips have been received regarding Nancy’s disappearance, per the outlet.

Pima County Sheriff’s Department

He also previously shared that it could take “years” to find Nancy.

“Maybe it’s an hour from now,” Nanos said of how long it could take to locate Nancy, per The New York Times. “Maybe it’s weeks or months or years from now. But we won’t quit. We’re going to find Nancy. We’re going to find this guy.”

“The one with the DNA profile recovered is different and appears to match the gloves of the subject in the surveillance video,” said the FBI spokesperson in a statement obtained on Sunday, Feb. 15.

FBI and SWAT units searching for Nancy Guthrie on Feb. 13.Brandon Bell/Getty

Savannah, 54, made an emotional plea to her mother’s kidnappers in an Instagram video shared later that day.

“I wanted to say to whoever has her or knows where she is that it’s never too late. And you’re not lost or alone,” she said. “And it is never too late to do the right thing. And we are here. And we believe. And we believe in the essential goodness of every human being.”

“It’s never too late,” Savannah concluded.

A $100,000 reward has been offered for any information leading to Nancy’s recovery or an arrest in the case.

The FBI is urging anyone with tips or leads to call 1-800-CALL-FBI in addition to the Pima County Sheriff’s Office number, 520-351-4900.

**”A GLIMMER OF LIGHT ON DAY 4. 🚨💪 Maya Gebala is showing the world what it means to fight. Nurses report that she is now trying to initiate her own breaths and is showing pupil response—small signs that mean everything in this critical hour.  The family’s message is simple: One breath at a time. They are seeing the progress they’ve been praying for. She isn’t giving up, and neither are we. Stay with us for the full update on Maya’s condition in the first comment.
“BEYOND THE BROADCAST. 📺💔 As the search for Savannah Guthrie’s family continues, Craig Melvin is proving that friendship goes far deeper than the studio lights. Choosing to step away from the headlines to offer his unwavering support, Craig’s gesture has touched the hearts of millions. In a world of constant noise, his silence speaks volumes. It’s a testament to a bond that refuses to let a colleague walk through the fire alone. We stand with Savannah, and we applaud the kindness that reminds us we are human first, and professionals second. 🕊️
“MORE THAN JUST COLLEAGUES. 📺💔 Putting humanity before the broadcast, Craig Melvin has paused his major career plans to support Savannah Guthrie during her family’s darkest hour. No search for medals, no chasing cameras—just the quiet power of being there. As the agony of the search continues, Craig’s decision serves as a beacon of light, reminding us all that showing up for each other is the most important role we can ever play. True friendship shines brightest in the shadows.
Why Sheriff Chris Nanos ruled out theory Nancy Guthrie’s abduction was burglary gone bad — The One Detail at the Scene That Investigators Say Doesn’t Add Up 🔍  Officials say the evidence left behind tells a very different story than a random break-in. No forced chaos, no rushed exit — just calculated movement. So if it wasn’t a burglary gone wrong… was it something far more deliberate? 👀